🛡️ Unarmored Leadership Newsletter: The Emotional Toll of Performing Under Pressure 🛡️


Hey, it's Susan 😀 Welcome to my monthly newsletter – a space where we explore the protective behaviors we develop under pressure, the emotional cost of performing, and what it means to lead with greater clarity, confidence, and connection.

Hi Reader,

It’s been a little while since I’ve written a newsletter, and honestly, I think part of the reason is that I’ve been sitting with – and living inside of – a deeper evolution of my work around pressure, performance, identity, and leadership.

Over the past few months, I’ve had conversations with leaders, clients, and groups that have reinforced something I can no longer ignore: when the stakes are high, many of us stop leading from who we are and start performing who we think we need to be.

🛡️ The Emotional Toll of Performing Under Pressure

There's a moment that happens for so many leaders in high-pressure situations.

You walk into a meeting, presentation, difficult conversation, or high-stakes opportunity and suddenly, without even realizing it, you stop being yourself.

You leave parts of yourself at the door and start managing how you're perceived - monitoring your tone, rehearsing your words in your head before saying them (if you say them at all), softening your language, over-explaining (to show why you deserve to be there), becoming more polished, more careful, and more robotic.

And once the moment passes, you don't remember what you said, berate yourself for how you showed up, or both.

Underneath all of this armor is often one powerful belief: "I am not enough for this moment as I am."

🛡️ Pressure Doesn't Just Impact Performance - It Reshapes Identity

One of the biggest misconceptions about high performance is that pressure simply affects execution. In reality, pressure often reshapes identity first.

In high-stakes moments, we begin relating to ourselves differently. It's almost like someone else takes over. Thoughts swirl around in our head:

  • I need to prove myself.
  • I can't get this wrong.
  • I need to sound like I know what I'm talking about.
  • I need to hold it together.
  • I need to look confident.

The problem isn't the thoughts themselves – it's that we start to focus on them. And for some of us, these thoughts are so loud and so strong that they don't just stay in our heads – they drive our behavior.

Suddenly, our communication becomes filtered or worse, we silence ourselves. Our presence also becomes performative – almost like you're on autopilot – you know it, and everyone else knows it, too. And our leadership becomes focused on self-protection instead of connection.

Here's why this is challenging: these behaviors are often rewarded in the short term. You receive praise for:

  • The polished presentation.
  • The perfect answer.
  • The carefully coiffed image.
  • Keeping your cool.

From the outside, this can look like high performance. But internally, it's full-blown exhaustion.

🛡️ The Emotional Toll No One Talks About

"I walk into certain meetings and immediately feel myself becoming smaller and more calculated. I can hear myself speaking differently in real time," one client shared recently.

Another told me: "I spend so much energy trying to sound like I know what I'm talking about that I leave conversations completely drained." Collective sigh...

This is the hidden emotional toll of performing under pressure. It's not because you're incapable or don't belong at the table. It's because trying to manage how you're being perceived while simultaneously leading sucks the life out of you.

If you do this long enough, it can create:

  • chronic hyper-vigilance and self-monitoring
  • decision fatigue
  • loss of self-trust
  • imposter syndrome
  • disconnection from your own instincts
  • burnout disguised as achievement

Many high performers don't even realize they're doing it, because armor works. It helps you succeed, advance, belong, avoid criticism, and maintain control. Until one day you realize you no longer know how to lead without pretending to be someone else.

🛡️ Sometimes Armor Looks Like Strength

Armor doesn't always look like fear or insecurity. Sometimes it looks like:

  • over-functioning
  • hyper-preparedness
  • emotional control
  • people-pleasing
  • perfectionism
  • shape-shifting in different rooms

I once had a client tell me shape-shifting was her superpower. When I asked her, "How's that going for you?" she sobbed and told me she doesn't know who she is anymore. That's because sometimes what gets praised as professionalism or emotional intelligence is actually self-erasure. Even bigger collective sigh...

🛡️ So What Do We Do Instead?

One of the practices I teach through Unarmored Leadership™ is a simple shift:

Notice. Align. Act.

1. Notice What's Activated

Pause long enough to notice what pressure is triggering in you.

  • What story are you telling yourself?
  • What are you afraid might happen?
  • What identity threat is surfacing?

Simply noticing creates space.

2. Align to What Matters

Ask yourself:

  • What matters most right now?
  • What value do I want leading me here? Clarity? Trust? Courage? Honesty?

Values help us move from reacting out of fear to responding with intention.

3. Take a Clear Next Step

It doesn't have to be perfect or polished – just one clear, aligned move. Maybe it's:

  • saying the thing you're holding back
  • asking a question
  • pausing instead of over-explaining
  • trusting yourself instead of rehearsing again

Small shifts change how we experience pressure.

🛡️ A Different Definition of High Performance

We've inherited a version of high performance that often rewards control, endurance, certainty, and self-protection.

But I want to offer a different definition: High performance is sustaining clarity, confidence, and connection under pressure 💥

Not becoming more impressive when the stakes are high, but becoming less divided: less split between who you are and how you lead.

Because your best leadership does not come from becoming someone else under pressure – it comes from staying connected to yourself.

🛡️ A Great Resource

My friend and coach extraordinaire Mark Guay has a great resource that helps decrease your stress and expand your capacity in less than 5 minutes. It’s called 7-Dimensional Breathing. I wanted to share it with you!

From a physiological standpoint, slow, intentional breathing stimulates the vagus nerve, increases heart rate variability, and shifts the nervous system from sympathetic activation to parasympathetic regulation. This transition improves emotional regulation, cognitive clarity, and the ability to make grounded decisions under pressure.

Somatically, the practice recognizes that the body stores patterns of tension shaped by past stress. By breathing dimensionally and expanding awareness through the body, you expand your capacity. Over time, resilience grows, which means you can handle for of what home and work throw your way.

🛡️ Work with Me

Unarmored Leadership™ is more than a framework – it’s a different way of understanding how pressure shapes identity, behavior, and performance, and how leaders can sustain clarity, confidence, and connection when the stakes are high.

I partner with leaders, teams, and organizations to explore what support would be most valuable for their goals, challenges, and environment. That work may include:

Workshops and Keynotes – Interactive experiences that help leaders and teams navigate pressure, strengthen trust, improve communication, and rethink high performance.

Group Coaching Programs – Reflective and supportive spaces to explore leadership alongside peers, practice new ways of showing up, and build accountability for meaningful change.

1:1 Executive Coaching – Personalized partnership for leaders who want to strengthen executive presence, communicate with greater clarity, navigate pressure more effectively, and lead in a way that feels both grounded and authentic.

If you’re curious about what this work could look like for you, your team, or your organization, I’d love to connect and explore what support might be most helpful.

Susan Eckstein's Unarmored Leadership

My monthly newsletter is full of insights on how to dismantle your ARMOR (the limiting beliefs, stories, and behaviors that prevent you from becoming who you want to be), how your armor protects you, and strategies to overcome resistance. It is designed to support your personal and professional growth, and I am excited to share it with you.

Read more from Susan Eckstein's Unarmored Leadership

Hey, it's Susan 😀 Welcome to my monthly newsletter on how to dismantle your armor — the protective behaviors that prevent you from leading with confidence, clarity, and connection. Hi Reader, Happy New Year! I hope you had a great holiday and were able to rest, relax, and recharge. For many people, the start of a new year is a time to set resolutions. While I've never been a fan of them, I appreciate the intention behind them: the desire to name who we want to become and what we're ready to...

Hey, it's Susan 😀 Welcome to my monthly newsletter on how to dismantle your armor - the protective behaviors that prevent you from leading with confidence, clarity, and connection. There’s a moment almost every woman can point to, the moment she realizes she has been playing a version of herself instead of showing up as who she truly is. One of mine happened in 2016. When I first started my coaching and speaking career, a personal training client invited me to give a talk about mindset at her...

Hey, it's Susan 😀 Welcome to my monthly newsletter on how to dismantle your armor - the protective behaviors that prevent you from leading with confidence, clarity, and connection. Hi, Reader, In a recent group coaching session, I posed a simple question to the group: "Who is the type of leader you admire and why?" You could see their minds working as they paused for a moment before offering their answers: "Someone who gives tough feedback in a kind way." "Someone who doesn’t rush you, even...