[Unarmored Leadership™ Newsletter] The Role of Emotions in Unarmored Leadership


Hey, it's Susan 😀 Welcome to my monthly newsletter on how to dismantle your armor - the protective behaviors that prevent you from leading with confidence, clarity, and connection.

Hi, Reader,

I recently coached an SVP at a financial services firm who shared that she often felt "off" at work. On paper, she was thriving — a respected leader, trusted by her team, and consistently delivering results. But privately, she described leaving meetings emotionally drained, frustrated, and questioning whether her contributions even mattered.

At first, she couldn’t put her finger on it. "It’s like I walk out of the room and feel deflated, but I can’t explain why," she told me. The sensation was vague yet persistent, and she knew something wasn’t right.

When we slowed down and explored what she was feeling more deeply, a clearer picture emerged. She wasn’t just feeling "off." She was battling a quiet, simmering anger every time her ideas were dismissed or derailed. Two of her colleagues routinely interrupted her, speaking over her mid-sentence, and she found herself shrinking to avoid conflict. The more it happened, the more she doubted herself.

This is what armor looks like in practice. For her, it was the armor of silence and over-preparation. She tried to contain her frustration by controlling what she could: rehearsing what she was going to say before her meetings, adjusting her tone to avoid being labeled "too emotional," and second-guessing whether to speak up at all. On the outside, she looked confident and put-together. On the inside, she felt small, unheard, and stuck.

The turning point came when she named the emotions beneath the surface. The bubbling anger and frustration weren’t signs of failure; they were signals. Signals that her core values of respect and contribution were being challenged.

Once she made that connection, everything shifted. Instead of fighting the anger or becoming defensive, she saw it as a source of information. It told her where boundaries were being crossed, what mattered most to her, and what needed to change.

From there, she began experimenting with small but powerful shifts: speaking up earlier in meetings instead of waiting for the "perfect" moment, naming interruptions calmly but directly, and anchoring herself in what she knew she brought to the table. Each step reinforced her presence and rebuilt her confidence.

For the first time in a long while, she wasn’t performing or holding back — she was leading as her true self. And the difference wasn’t just inside her. Her team noticed the change. They described her as being more grounded, approachable, and inspiring.

Why Emotions Matter in Leadership

Many leaders I speak with believe emotions are a liability and that showing them will make them seem weak, unprofessional, or less credible. They’ve been told to "leave your feelings at the door," or "never let them see you sweat."

But here’s the truth: emotions are not the problem. Emotions are information. They are signals pointing to what matters most — what you value, where your boundaries are, and when something is out of alignment.

When you avoid, suppress, or ignore those signals, armor takes over. It may show up as over-explaining to cover insecurity, lashing out in frustration, retreating into silence, or disengaging to avoid conflict. These protective behaviors may give you temporary relief, but the cost is high. Armor slowly erodes trust, creates disconnection with others, and feeds self-doubt.

Over time, this pattern leaves you feeling anxious before big meetings, frustrated when you can’t be fully heard, or unsettled because you're not being your authentic self. What began as a strategy for safety ultimately becomes a barrier to presence, authenticity, and impact.

The leaders who learn to pause, name what they’re feeling, and use that information as guidance instead of suppression find something different: clarity, agency, and a renewed ability to lead with grounded confidence.

From Awareness to Agency

Self-awareness is the foundation of Unarmored Leadership. It’s where everything begins. But awareness on its own isn’t enough. Many leaders can name that they feel "off," but if they stop there, the feeling lingers without clarity or resolution. The real shift happens when awareness is paired with agency and action.

Awareness: Start by noticing and naming what you’re actually feeling in the moment. Instead of "I’m fine," practice being specific: "I feel anxious," "I feel frustrated," or "I feel hopeful." Naming the emotion takes away some of its power over you. It creates space between you and the feeling.

Agency: Once you’ve named the emotion, the next step is reflection. Ask yourself: "What is this emotion guiding me toward? What value or boundary is being pressed here?" For example, anger might signal that your value of respect is being crossed. Anxiety might reveal a fear of failure bumping up against your value of excellence. Agency is about understanding the message behind the emotion.

Action: From there, you get to choose. Instead of reacting on autopilot, you intentionally select a response that aligns with your values and desired impact. If frustration signals a boundary is being crossed, your action might be to calmly set a limit instead of snapping back. If anxiety is surfacing, your action could be to slow down, breathe, and ground yourself before speaking.

When you practice this cycle — Awareness → Agency → Action — emotions stop feeling like liabilities and become information you can use. This is what allows you to lead in integrity: responding with clarity, courage, and presence rather than from a place of fear or armor.

The Impact of Naming Emotions

When you incorporate this practice into your daily routines, the impact is both personal and relational. By noticing, naming, and working with your emotions rather than against them, you begin to lead from a place of presence instead of protection. This shift not only changes how you feel, but also how others experience you as a leader.

  • Build trust by responding in a way that conveys authenticity and sincerity. People sense when you’re being real with them — it fosters psychological safety and strengthens connection.
  • Increase your resilience by no longer wasting energy suppressing your true feelings or pretending to be someone you're not. Instead of forcing yourself to be "on" or perform, you free up energy to focus on what matters most.
  • Strengthen your clarity and presence by listening to your inner leader, rather than resorting to the armor of silence, perfectionism, or control. This allows you to respond with intention, rather than falling back on automatic habits.

And perhaps most importantly, you feel lighter and free to lead in a way that feels good to you. You're no longer consumed by self-doubt and performance, but free to lead in alignment with who you really are. Over time, this isn’t just a leadership skill; it becomes a way of leading that fuels both your impact and your wellbeing.

Reflection Prompt for Readers

The next time you notice yourself armoring up — whether by staying silent, over-explaining, or becoming defensive — pause and ask yourself: What am I actually feeling right now? And what do I want to do with that information?

If you’d like support in practicing how to name and work with your emotions, let’s talk.

🛡️Unarmoring Resource🛡️

I've been reading Emotional Agility: Get Unstuck, Embrace Change, and Thrive in Work and Life, by Susan David, PhD. According to Dr. David, "emotional agility means having any number of troubling thoughts or emotions and still managing to act in a way that serves how you most want to live."

She shares an example I believe a lot of people can relate to: "You can have the thought that you're a fake, notice it, and then purposefully choose to set it aside, because what's more important is making a meaningful contribution to this meeting you're in right now... You are not ignoring or denying or trying to suppress the thought. Rather, you are curiously noticing it and the information it brings, but not letting it call the shots."

This is Unarmored Leadership in action — realizing you have agency in the moment and can choose to show up aligned with your beliefs and values. When you stop letting emotions or self-doubt dictate your behavior, you reclaim your ability to lead with steadiness and integrity. Over time, these small choices build resilience, trust, and the freedom to lead without needing to perform.

🛡️ Work With Me 🛡️

Unarmored Leadership™ is more than a framework - it’s a practice that transforms how leaders show up for themselves, their teams, and their organizations.

I offer:

  • 1:1 Executive and Leadership Coaching — Personalized support to dismantle the armor that limits your impact, strengthen your presence, and lead with confidence and authenticity.
  • Group Coaching Programs — A supportive space to explore leadership with peers, practice new ways of showing up, and build accountability for lasting change.
  • Workshops & Keynotes — Engaging sessions for teams, affinity groups, ERGs, and organizations looking to navigate uncertainty, build trust, and unlock the power of authentic leadership, with or without LEGO®.

If you’re curious about how Unarmored Leadership can support you, your team, or your organization, I’d love to connect.

Susan Eckstein's Unarmored Leadership

My monthly newsletter is full of insights on how to dismantle your ARMOR (the limiting beliefs, stories, and behaviors that prevent you from becoming who you want to be), how your armor protects you, and strategies to overcome resistance. It is designed to support your personal and professional growth, and I am excited to share it with you.

Read more from Susan Eckstein's Unarmored Leadership

Hey, it's Susan 😀 Welcome to my monthly newsletter – a space where we explore the protective behaviors we develop under pressure, the emotional cost of performing, and what it means to lead with greater clarity, confidence, and connection. Hi Reader, It’s been a little while since I’ve written a newsletter, and honestly, I think part of the reason is that I’ve been sitting with – and living inside of – a deeper evolution of my work around pressure, performance, identity, and leadership. Over...

Hey, it's Susan 😀 Welcome to my monthly newsletter on how to dismantle your armor — the protective behaviors that prevent you from leading with confidence, clarity, and connection. Hi Reader, Happy New Year! I hope you had a great holiday and were able to rest, relax, and recharge. For many people, the start of a new year is a time to set resolutions. While I've never been a fan of them, I appreciate the intention behind them: the desire to name who we want to become and what we're ready to...

Hey, it's Susan 😀 Welcome to my monthly newsletter on how to dismantle your armor - the protective behaviors that prevent you from leading with confidence, clarity, and connection. There’s a moment almost every woman can point to, the moment she realizes she has been playing a version of herself instead of showing up as who she truly is. One of mine happened in 2016. When I first started my coaching and speaking career, a personal training client invited me to give a talk about mindset at her...